Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dr. Randy M. Kaplan's avatar

Really, in the midst of all this profound and idiotic reporting, a moment of beautiful thought from Descartes. Hey, how could the algorithm let this through? I definitely think it is a failure of Substack’s entity - you know all knowing and all powerful. Must be a bug.

Expand full comment
Max Kern's avatar

I don’t mean to take Descartes’ moment by the fire away from him. Nor do I wish to deprive you of your reverence for the great philosopher. But between us – among those of us who value the free-spirited, headstrong, and critically questioning mind – something must be said.

Because none of that quite matches the Descartes I’ve encountered.

Yes, he was a sharp mathematician and philosopher. But he was also a product of his time – a time when the Catholic Church held a tight grip on thought, and when any new idea risked being labeled heresy. In that climate, Descartes moved with care and calculation.

His Meditations are not only an introspective journey toward certainty; they’re also a diplomatic document – a white paper crafted to appease a watchful Church. “Cogito, ergo sum” may have planted the seed of the modern self, but no sooner has he sown it than he waters it with an affirmation of God’s existence. Almost as if to say: I think, therefore I am – but God is still greater.

If I’m to read him charitably – and I want to – perhaps this is where his cunning brilliance emerges most clearly. The God he invokes may not be an expression of piety, but of survival.

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts